Attached is a comparison of party platforms and promises to date. It is by no means an exhaustive list and several things should be taken into consideration while reading. Platforms are being added to on a daily basis. This is simply a snapshot to this point.
Green and Bloc are silent, or at least it is difficult to find information, on several items – this was not a conscious decision to ignore - it was simply based on availability.
The order of how they were listed is unintentional other than the three major parties were listed in order of seats at dissolution. Read nothing more into that please, this was not meant to be a partisan document. Apart from one item (the GST), we only dealt with platform issues where we could find at least two platforms from different parties.
Sent on behalf of the Political Action Committee
Robert Campbell
National President, UTE
Party Platforms (Promises)
The Economy
|
Conservative Party of Canada |
New Democratic Party |
Liberal Party of Canada |
Green Party of Canada |
Bloc Quebecois |
Budgets |
Introduced Balanced Budget Legislation and promises to balance the budget |
Promised to balance its first budget |
Would run modest deficits until they saw growth |
|
|
Corporate and Business Tax |
Lowered corporate taxes to 12%. Promises to lower small business tax to 9% |
Will raise corporate taxes to 17% and close loopholes. Will lower small business tax to 9% |
Committed to maintain the current corporate tax structure |
End corporate bailouts, raise corporate taxes and keep small business taxes low |
Increase Corporate taxes to 16.5%, raise tax rates to 20% on banks and oil companies |
Personal Tax |
|
|
Increase tax rate to 33% for those earning over $200,000. Reduce the rate for those earning $44,700-$89,400 |
|
Impose 1.5% extra tax on those earning above $150,000 |
GST |
|
|
|
|
Abolish the GST on books |
TFSA |
Raised from $5,500 to $10,000 |
Will revert to $5,500 |
Will revert to $5,500 |
|
|
Wages |
Does not support a federal minimum wage |
Proposed a $15/hr federal minimum wage |
Does not support a federal minimum wage of $15/hr |
|
|
Income Splitting |
Implemented |
Will Cancel |
Will Cancel |
|
|
Social Issues
Mail Delivery |
Moving to community mailboxes |
Will restore door-to-door delivery |
Will restore door-to-door delivery |
|
Maintain home delivery in Quebec |
Census |
Eliminated long-form census |
Will restore long-form census |
Will restore long-form census |
|
|
Child Care |
Increased the Universal Child Care Benefit |
Will introduce $15/day national childcare program, honour the Universal Child Care Benefit |
Work to provide access to affordable childcare, introduce income-tested tax-free benefit for those making less than $150K |
|
|
Post-Secondary Education |
|
Increase transfer funds to provinces to lower tuition, eliminate interest on student loans |
Invest more in education with bursaries and loans |
Invest in undergraduate research fellowships |
|
Health Care |
Committed to increasing the Health Care Transfer “on a predictable and sustainable path” over the next 5 years |
Invest $300 million to build new health care clinics, hire 7000 doctors and nurse practitioners, 5000 more hospital beds, national plan to improve access to prescription drugs |
Committed to working with the provinces, improve wait times, improve affordability of prescription drugs and home-care |
|
|
Drug Use |
National toll-free line, increase funding to RCMP Clandestine Laboratory Team, considering a new police ticketing procedure for small amounts of marijuana |
Immediately decriminalize marijuana possession |
Immediately legalize marijuana |
Legalize and regulate marijuana |
|
Public Transit |
$750 million over two years and $1B annually thereafter |
$1.3B annually over next 20 years |
$6B over next 4 years and almost $20B over the next 20 years |
|
|
Retirement |
Introduced pension income splitting in 2007, raised the age of eligibility for Old Age Security to 67 from 65, will consider additional voluntary Canada Pension Plan contributions |
Will keep pension income splitting, will boost the Guaranteed Income Supplement by $400 million annually, will restore the age of eligibility for Old Age Security to 65 |
Will legislate additional CPP contributions, will restore the age of eligibility for Old Age Security to 65, boost the Guaranteed Income Supplement by 10% |
|
|
Aboriginal Affairs
Truth and Reconciliation Commission Report |
Study the recommendations |
Consult with first nations and prioritize the implementation of the Commission’s recommendations |
Implement full recommendations |
Act on the Commission’s recommendations |
|
Missing and Murdered Aboriginal Women |
|
Call public inquiry within 100 days |
Call public inquiry |
Call public Inquiry |
|
Nutrition North |
|
Commitment to fix the program by increasing funding and eligibility |
Have called the program a failure and have voted on motions to increase eligibility |
|
|
Aboriginal Education |
Funded new skills training programs |
Invest in First Nations education |
Increase First Nations education spending by $2.6B over 4 years |
|
|
Governance
Electoral System |
Status Quo, introduce legislation that a national referendum would have to be held before the system is changed |
Replace the First-Past-The-Post system with Mixed Member Proportional Representation |
Eliminate the First-Past-The-Post system and study ranked ballots, proportional representation, mandatory voting and online voting |
Eliminate the First-Past-The-Post system and consult on proportional representation |
|
The Senate |
Self-imposed moratorium on appointments, favours electing the senators or eliminating the Senate but this is on hold |
Abolish the Senate |
Favours a non-partisan independent appointment board for Senators, not allowed to sit in caucus |
Elect Senators |
|
Parliamentary Budget Officer |
Created in 2006 |
To make the officer fully independent and free from influence |
Strengthen the role of independent parliamentary watchdog agencies |
|
|
International/Military
Bill C-51 |
Passed in 2015 |
Would repeal Bill C-51 |
Voted for C-51 but would introduce oversight if elected |
Favours more oversight |
|
Veterans Affairs |
$193 million towards services for veterans |
Re-open 9 offices |
Re-open 9 offices |
Provide Veterans Affairs the resources it needs to service veterans |
|
Foreign Aid |
$3.5B towards maternal and child health in Africa |
Increase foreign aid to 0.7% of gross national income |
Reverse the dropping trend of foreign aid as a percentage of GDP |
Development assistance to the poorest of the poor |
|
Environment
Climate Change/Emissions |
Sector by sector regulations, low carbon footprint by 2050 end to fossil fuels by end of century, |
Create cap and trade system, redirect $1B from fossil fuel subsidies to clean energy initiatives |
Work with provinces to put a price on carbon |
Introduce a carbon fee, reduce emission to 40% less than 2005 levels by 2025 |
|
Keystone XL Pipeline |
Support |
Oppose |
Support |
|
|
Public Service and Unions
C-59 Sick Leave |
Introduced |
Committed to undo the changes in C-59 regarding sick leave. |
Opposed to the provisions regarding sick leave, will ensure bargaining is “fair and reasonable” |
|
|
Collective Bargaining |
|
Will honour the process as determined by the courts as a right, will repeal any legislation that contains language contrary to that right |
Has committed to respect the bargaining process and the “important role unions play” |
|
|
Bill C-377 Bill C-525 |
Introduced both |
Will repeal both |
Will repeal both |
|
|
Canada Revenue Agency |
|
Commitment to cracking down on tax evasion and money laundering |
“significant overhaul” to fight international tax evasion and ending “political harassment” of charities |
|
|
Public Service As a Whole |
|
No new spending cuts, Establish a code of conduct for ministers and their staff to “ensure ministers stop blaming the public service when things go wrong, introduce legislation to better protect the anonymity of whistleblowers |
Spending review, new performance standards for services offered by the federal government, starting with veterans’ services, immigration processing, Employment Insurance and Canada Pension Plan processing, and appeals at the Social Security Tribunal |
|
|
References:
http://news.nationalpost.com/news/canada/canadian-politics/everything-you-need-to-know-about-the-parties-platforms http://www.thestar.com/news/canada/2015/06/23/federal-election-2015-what-the-parties-are-promising.html http://hkstrategies.ca/english/federal-election-2015-party-promises-economic-and-fiscal-issues/ http://news.nationalpost.com/news/canada/canadian-politics/stephen-harper-writes-open-letter-to-canadas-world-class-public-service-in-order-to-correct-misinformation http://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/canada-election-2015-bloc-election-promises-1.3246596